Updated November 2026
Carlisle tires for ATV riders cover everything from light trail work to deep mud, and choosing the wrong size or tread can hurt handling and traction fast. This list is built from manufacturer specifications, product listings and common owner feedback, weighing tread style, ply rating, tire size and the riding conditions each model is designed for. Use it to match a Carlisle tire to how you actually ride.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallCarlisle All Trail II 24×10.50-10View on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for budget front-and-rear setsSunF Power.I A033 Set 25×8-12 Front and 25×10-12 RearView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for mudCarlisle AT489 AT25x10-12 4 Ply Mud TireView on Amazon - 4
Best for all-season 25-inch fitmentCarlisle AT489 All-Season Bias Tire 25/10-12 84BView on Amazon - 5
Best for heavy loadsCarlisle AT489 ATV Bias Tire 25×11.00-12 4PRView on Amazon - 6
Best for narrow rear clearanceCarlisle All Trail ATV Tire 25X9-12View on Amazon - 7
Best for 2- or 4-wheel drive riders4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" TView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Carlisle All Trail II 24×10.50-10 | Overall trail use | 4-ply bias, all-terrain tread |
| SunF Power.I A033 set | Front and rear set buyers | 6-ply tubeless, matched sizes |
| Carlisle AT489 AT25x10-12 | Mud riding | Deep aggressive lugs |
| Carlisle AT489 25/10-12 84B | All-season fitment | Standard 25-inch size |
| Carlisle AT489 25×11.00-12 | Heavy loads | 4PR load rating |
| Carlisle All Trail 25×9-12 | Tight rear clearance | Narrow profile |
| Non-directional A tread set | 2WD and 4WD machines | Non-directional, 6-ply |
Carlisle All Trail II 24×10.50-10
CarlisleATV & UTV All Terrain All Season Traction 76F Rated 4 Ply Bias Construction Black Sidewall Tire All Trail II ATV Tire – 24X10.50-10
Best for: Overall trail use with a 10-inch rim
This suits riders on smaller-frame machines who want a balanced all-terrain tire for mixed trail and gravel.
- Pros: Balanced all-terrain tread; 4-ply bias construction
- Pros: Common size for older and smaller ATVs
- Cons: Less aggressive than dedicated mud tires
SunF Power.I A033 Set 25×8-12 Front and 25×10-12 Rear
Best for: Front and rear set buyers on a budget
Owners who want matched front and rear tires in one order often choose this set for trail and light mud use.
- Pros: Complete four-tire set with matched sizes
- Pros: 6-ply tubeless construction
- Cons: Not a Carlisle-branded tire, so check the listing carefully
Carlisle AT489 AT25x10-12 4 Ply Mud Tire
CarlisleATV & UTV All Terrain All Season Traction 29F Rated 2-Star Bias Construction Black Sidewall Tire AT489 Mud Tire – AT25X10-12 4 Ply
Best for: Mud riding
Riders who spend time in soft, wet ground typically look for the deeper lug pattern of the AT489 line.
- Pros: Deep lugs for mud and soft soil
- Pros: 4-ply bias construction
- Cons: Louder and less smooth on hard-packed trails
Carlisle AT489 All-Season Bias Tire 25/10-12 84B
Best for: All-season 25-inch fitment
This is a common choice for riders who want one tire that handles trail, gravel and light mud without changing setups.
- Pros: Standard 25-inch size with wide fitment
- Pros: Good all-season versatility
- Cons: Not as aggressive as a dedicated mud tread
Carlisle AT489 ATV Bias Tire 25×11.00-12 4PR
Best for: Heavy loads and hauling
Utility riders hauling gear or towing will often look at the 4PR rating and wider 11-inch section.
- Pros: 4PR rating for added load capacity
- Pros: Wider footprint for stability under weight
- Cons: Wider section may rub on tight fender setups
Carlisle All Trail ATV Tire 25X9-12
Best for: Tight rear clearance
A narrower 9-inch section helps when fender or swingarm clearance is limited on the rear.
- Pros: Narrower profile for tight wheel wells
- Pros: All-trail tread for mixed use
- Cons: Less float in deep, soft mud
