Updated November 2026

Choosing the best ATV tires for mud and trail riding comes down to a few measurable things: tread depth and spacing, sidewall ply rating, bead and tubeless construction, and whether the size matches your rims and suspension clearance. This guide compares seven all-terrain and mud-oriented tire sets from the Amazon US catalog. Each pick is judged on what the listing and manufacturer specifications state, what owners commonly report about traction and durability, and how well the tread suits mixed mud, sand, gravel, and packed trail. No pick here is claimed as tested in our own shop.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1SunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25x8-12 Front & 25x10-12 RearTOP CHOICEBest overallSunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25×8-12 Front & 25×10-12 RearView on Amazon
  2. 2Set of 4 SunF A050 26x9-12 Front & 26x11-12 Rear Deep Mud + Trail ATVTOP CHOICEBest for deep mudSet of 4 SunF A050 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear Deep Mud + Trail ATVView on Amazon
  3. 3FORERUNNER 25x8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Off-Road Tires (Pack of 2, Tubeless)TOP CHOICEBest for mixed trail and sandFORERUNNER 25×8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Off-Road Tires (Pack of 2, Tubeless)View on Amazon
  4. 4MaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires, 6 PR, TubelessBest budget pickMaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires, 6 PR, TubelessView on Amazon
  5. 54pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" TBest for 2 or 4 wheel drive setups4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" TView on Amazon
  6. 6GarveeAll Terrain 25x8x12 Tubeless Tires for Mud, Trail, Sand, GravelBest for street-legal mixed useGarveeAll Terrain 25x8x12 Tubeless Tires for Mud, Trail, Sand, GravelView on Amazon
  7. 7Garvee Set of 2 25x10-12 ATV Tires, 6-Ply Tubeless All-Terrain Mud/Trail Off-Road TiresBest single-pair upgradeGarvee Set of 2 25×10-12 ATV Tires, 6-Ply Tubeless All-Terrain Mud/Trail Off-Road TiresView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
SunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25×8-12 / 25×10-12 Balanced trail and mud use 6-ply tubeless, staggered front and rear sizes
FORERUNNER 25×8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Tires Mixed trail, sand, and mud 6PR tubeless, sold as a pack of two
Garvee 25×10-12 ATV Tires (Set of 2) Single-pair replacement 6-ply tubeless mud and trail tread
SunF A050 26×9-12 / 26×11-12 Deep Mud + Trail Deep mud and soft ground Larger 26-inch footprint, deep lugs
MaxAuto AT25x8-12 / AT25x10-12 Mud Sand Tires Budget full-set replacement 6 PR tubeless all-terrain construction
4pcs 25x8x12 / 25x10x12 Non-Directional “A” Tread ATV Tires 2WD and 4WD machines Non-directional tread, rotatable
Garvee All Terrain 25x8x12 / 25x10x12 Set of 4 Mud, gravel, and some street use Heavy-duty all-terrain design

SunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25×8-12 Front & 25×10-12 Rear

Set of 4 SunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25x8-12 Front & 25x10-12 Rear, 6 PR, Tubeless A033

Set of 4 SunF Power.I ATV UTV all-terrain Tires 25×8-12 Front & 25×10-12 Rear, 6 PR, Tubeless A033

View on Amazon

Best for: Balanced trail and mud use with a staggered front and rear setup

This set suits riders who split time between woods trails, wet clay, and occasional open-field riding. The staggered sizing matches the common 25-inch front and wider rear fitment on many mid-size ATVs.

Key specs

  • Front size 25×8-12, rear size 25×10-12
  • 6-ply rating (6 PR)
  • Tubeless construction
  • Set of 4

Pros

  • Staggered sizing fits typical 25-inch ATV setups
  • Six-ply sidewalls are commonly reported as firmer under load
  • Tread works reasonably well across mud and packed trail

Cons

  • Lug pattern is less aggressive than dedicated deep-mud tires
  • Owners sometimes mention a break-in period for traction

Bottom line: A strong default choice for riders who want one set that handles most trail and mud conditions without a specialty focus.

View on Amazon

FORERUNNER 25×8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Off-Road Tires (Pack of 2, Tubeless)

FORERUNNER 6PR 25x8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Off-Road Tires FORERUNNER 25x8-12 ATV Tires,All Terrain TRS (Pack of 2, Tubeless)

FORERUNNER 6PR 25×8-12 ATV UTV Trail Mud Sand Off-Road Tires FORERUNNER 25×8-12 ATV Tires,All Terrain TRS (Pack of 2, Tubeless)

View on Amazon

Best for: Mixed trail, sand, and mud on a rear or front pair

This pack of two suits riders replacing one axle at a time or running a matched pair on the front. The trail-oriented tread is aimed at riders who ride more sand and packed dirt than deep bog.

Key specs

  • Size 25×8-12
  • 6PR rating
  • Tubeless
  • Pack of 2

Pros

  • Easy to add a matched pair without buying a full set
  • Tread handles sand and packed trail well
  • Tubeless design simplifies low-pressure running

Cons

  • Not a full four-tire set, so front and rear sizing must be matched separately
  • Less lug depth than the deepest mud-focused options

Bottom line: Best for riders who need a pair for one axle and mostly ride trail and sand with some mud.

View on Amazon

Garvee Set of 2 25×10-12 ATV Tires, 6-Ply Tubeless All-Terrain Mud/Trail Off-Road Tires

Garvee Set of 2 25x10-12 ATV Tires, 6-Ply Tubeless All-Terrain Mud/Trail Off-Road Tires, 25x10x12

Garvee Set of 2 25×10-12 ATV Tires, 6-Ply Tubeless All-Terrain Mud/Trail Off-Road Tires, 25x10x12

View on Amazon

Best for: Single-pair upgrade on a rear or front axle

This two-tire option works for riders who only need to replace worn rears or want a wider rear footprint for mud. Matching tread and ply rating to the existing front tires is important for stable steering.

Key specs

  • Size 25×10-12
  • 6-ply tubeless
  • Set of 2
  • All-terrain mud and trail tread

Pros

  • Flexible for replacing one axle
  • Six-ply construction is a common expectation for trail use
  • Wider 10-inch rear section adds mud footprint

Cons

  • Must match existing front tires for consistent handling
  • Pair-only purchase means no full-set cost savings

Bottom line: A practical pick for owners who want to replace only the rears and keep their current fronts.

View on Amazon

SunF A050 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear Deep Mud + Trail ATV UTV Off-Road Tires, 6PR, Tubeless

Set of 4 SunF A050 26x9-12 Front & 26x11-12 Rear Deep Mud + Trail ATV UTV Off-Road Tires, 6PR, Tubeless

Set of 4 SunF A050 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear Deep Mud + Trail ATV UTV Off-Road Tires, 6PR, Tubeless

View on Amazon

Best for: Deep mud and soft, wet ground

The larger 26-inch sizing gives more contact area in soft ground. This set is aimed at riders who regularly work through bog, flooded ruts, and thick clay where tread depth matters most.

Key specs

  • Front 26×9-12, rear 26×11-12
  • 6PR rating
  • Tubeless
  • Set of 4

Pros

  • Larger footprint helps flotation in soft ground
  • Deep-mud tread aimed at heavy clay
  • Full set keeps sizing consistent

Cons

  • Requires confirming rim width and suspension and fender clearance
  • Heavier than 25-inch sets, which can affect steering effort

Bottom line: Pick this if your riding is mostly deep mud and you have confirmed clearance for 26-inch tires.

View on Amazon

MaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires, 6 PR, Tubeless

MaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires,25x8x12 Front & 25x10x12 Rear All-Terrain Off-Road Tires,6 PR, Tubeless,4 Pack in 2 Packages

MaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires,25x8x12 Front & 25x10x12 Rear All-Terrain Off-Road Tires,6 PR, Tubeless,4 Pack in 2 Packages

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget full-set replacement

A budget-minded full set for riders who want all four corners matched without premium pricing. It fits riders who ride a few days a month and want reliable all-terrain performance.

Key specs

  • Front AT25x8-12, rear AT25x10-12
  • 6 PR tubeless
  • Set of 4 in two packages

Pros

  • Full set keeps front and rear matched
  • Tubeless construction for low-pressure trail running
  • Mud and sand tread suits general trail work

Cons

  • Brand has a smaller track record than the largest ATV tire names
  • Deep-mud performance is more limited than dedicated mud tread

Bottom line: A sensible budget full set for trail riders who do not spend most of their time in deep bog.

View on Amazon

4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires, 6 PR, Non-Directional “A” Tread for 2 or 4 Wheel Drive ATV/UTV

4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" Tread for 2 Or 4 Wheel Drive Atv Applications ATV/UTV Tires 25x8-12 Front & 25x10-12 Rear,6-Ply Tubeless,Set of 4

4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" Tread for 2 Or 4 Wheel Drive Atv Applications ATV/UTV Tires 25×8-12 Front & 25×10-12 Rear,6-Ply Tubeless,Set of 4

View on Amazon

Best for: 2WD and 4WD machines and tire rotation

The non-directional tread means the tires can be rotated front to back or side to side, which helps owners get more life out of a set. Suits both two- and four-wheel-drive machines.

Key specs

  • Front 25×8-12, rear 25×10-12
  • 6-ply rating
  • Tubeless
  • Non-directional “A” tread

Pros

  • Non-directional tread allows rotation
  • Works for 2WD and 4WD setups
  • Set of 4 keeps sizing matched

Cons

  • Non-directional tread is a compromise compared with deep directional mud lugs
  • Less specialized for extreme bog

Bottom line: Good for owners who want rotation flexibility and run a mix of 2WD and 4WD trail conditions.

View on Amazon

Garvee All Terrain 25x8x12 Tubeless Tires for Mud, Trail, Sand, Gravel & Street Set of 4

GarveeAll Terrain 25x8x12 Tubeless Tires for Mud, Trail, Sand, Gravel & Street, Heavy-Duty Design for Off-Road Riding Set of 4 AT25X8-12 & AT25X10-12 6PR ATV UTV Tires

GarveeAll Terrain 25x8x12 Tubeless Tires for Mud, Trail, Sand, Gravel & Street, Heavy-Duty Design for Off-Road Riding Set of 4 AT25X8-12 & AT25X10-12 6PR ATV UTV Tires

View on Amazon

Best for: Mud, gravel, and mixed on-road use

A heavy-duty all-terrain option for riders who cross gravel roads and pavement between trail sections. The tread is broad enough for everyday mixed use.

Key specs

  • Front AT25X8-12, rear AT25X10-12
  • 6PR rating
  • Tubeless
  • Set of 4

Pros

  • Versatile across mud, gravel, sand, and short road stretches
  • Heavy-duty design suited to repeated trail use
  • Full set for consistent handling

Cons

  • Road-oriented tread may feel noisier on pavement
  • Not as aggressive as dedicated mud tires in deep bog

Bottom line: A good choice when your ATV sees a lot of mixed surfaces and you want one set that tolerates them.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Tread Pattern and Depth

Directional lugs with wide spacing clear mud better than tight block patterns. Deeper lugs bite into soft ground, but they can feel rougher on hardpack. Match tread depth to your most common terrain rather than your rarest.

Good picks for this: SunF A050 26×9-12 Deep Mud + Trail, Garvee All Terrain 25x8x12 Set of 4

Ply Rating and Sidewall Strength

Six-ply (6 PR) sidewalls are common across trail-oriented ATV tires and help resist punctures and sidewall cuts from rocks and stumps. Ply rating is a useful comparison point, but also check load rating for your machine.

Good picks for this: SunF Power.I 25×8-12 / 25×10-12, Garvee Set of 2 25×10-12

Tire Size and Rim Fit

Confirm the stated size (for example 25×8-12 front and 25×10-12 rear) matches your rim diameter and width. Mismatched rim widths can affect bead seating and handling. Check fender and suspension clearance before buying 26-inch sizes.

Good picks for this: SunF Power.I 25×8-12 / 25×10-12, MaxAuto AT25x8-12 / AT25x10-12

Front and Rear Staggering

Many ATVs use a narrower front and wider rear tire. Staggered sets are designed for that layout. Buying a full matched set avoids steering inconsistency compared with mixing unrelated sizes.

Good picks for this: 4pcs 25x8x12 & 25x10x12 Non-Directional “A” Tread, MaxAuto Set of 4

Tubeless Construction and Rim Compatibility

Tubeless tires need a sealing rim and are generally run at low trail pressures. Confirm your wheels are tubeless-compatible before ordering, and carry a tire repair kit for trail use.

Good picks for this: FORERUNNER 25×8-12 Pack of 2, Garvee Set of 2 25×10-12

Riding Terrain and Use Case

Mud-heavy riding calls for deeper directional lugs and larger footprints. Trail and sand riding favors moderate tread. Mixed use with gravel roads favors all-terrain designs with smoother central tread.

Good picks for this: SunF A050 26×9-12 Deep Mud, Garvee All Terrain 25x8x12 Set of 4

Durability and Care

Check tire pressure before every ride and reduce pressure only as far as the manufacturer or your rim supplier recommends. Clean mud from the bead area after rides, inspect sidewalls for cuts, and rotate tires where the tread design allows.

Good picks for this: 4pcs 25x8x12 Non-Directional “A” Tread, SunF Power.I Set of 4

FAQ

What size ATV tires are best for mud?

Most riders use 25-inch sets for general trail and mud, and 26-inch sets where the machine has clearance and the terrain is consistently deep and soft. Confirm rim diameter and width before buying.

Is 6-ply better than 4-ply for trail riding?

Six-ply sidewalls are generally more resistant to punctures and cuts than four-ply, which is why many trail-oriented sets list 6 PR. Ply rating is one factor alongside tread design and load rating.

Can I mix tread patterns front and rear?

Mixing is possible but not always ideal. Matched patterns give more predictable steering and traction. If you mix, keep front and rear sizes correct for your machine.

Do I need tubeless tires for mud riding?

Tubeless tires are easier to run at low trail pressures and resist flats from thorns and small punctures when properly sealed. Your rims must be tubeless-compatible.

How often should I check tire pressure on the trail?

Check pressure before each ride and again after a long run, since heat and terrain changes affect it. Follow the manufacturer’s recommended pressure range for your tire and load.

Should I replace all four tires at once?

Replacing all four keeps wear and grip consistent and avoids steering differences. Replacing only the rear pair is common when the fronts still have adequate tread.

Conclusion

For a balanced set that handles most trail and mud, the SunF Power.I 25-inch staggered set is a strong starting point. Riders focused on deep bog should look at the SunF A050 26-inch deep-mud set, provided clearance is confirmed. Budget-minded buyers may prefer the MaxAuto full set, while owners replacing one axle can consider the Garvee or FORERUNNER pairs. Mixed-surface riders who also cover gravel roads may find the Garvee all-terrain set most versatile. Always confirm size, rim fit, and clearance before buying.

Sources

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our ATV, UTV/side-by-side & dirt bikes guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.