Updated November 2026

Shopping for 23×10 12 ATV tires means balancing load rating, tread style and how you actually ride. This list compares six sets sold on Amazon US based on product listings, brand reputation and common owner feedback patterns. Each pick is judged on tread type, ply rating, sizing and the terrain it suits most.

Best overall: WANDA 24×10-12 ATV Tires (Set 2-10432) – View on Amazon
Best for mud: WANDA ATV Tires 24x10x12 6PR Lit Mud – View on Amazon
Best for heavy loads: Set of 2 24×10-12 All-Terrain ATV UTV Tires, 6 Ply – View on Amazon
Best for utility use: WANDA Utility ATV Tire 23×11-10 – View on Amazon
Best for all-terrain mixed use: WANDA POWER-TRAIL Set 4 All Terrain ATV Tires – View on Amazon
Best budget-friendly pick: Garvee Pack of 2 AT25x10-12 ATV Tire – View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
WANDA 23X10.5-12 Golf Cart ATV Tires Light trail and golf-style use 4 ply construction
WANDA ATV Tires 24×10-12 Lit Mud Deep mud 6 ply mud tread
Set of 2 24×10-12 All-Terrain ATV UTV Tires Heavy loads 6 ply tubeless
WANDA ATV & UTV All Terrain 23×11-10 Utility work 98A3 rated, high load
WANDA POWER-TRAIL Set 4 All Terrain Mixed terrain Solid non-directional lugs
Garvee 6-Ply AT25x10-12 ATV Tire Budget trail riding Tubeless 6 ply rating

WANDA 23X10.5-12 Golf Cart ATV Tires 4 Ply 23X10.5×12 -Set 4-14034

WANDA 23X10.5-12 Golf Cart ATV Tires 4 Ply 23X10.5x12 -Set 4-14034 …

WANDA 23X10.5-12 Golf Cart ATV Tires 4 Ply 23X10.5×12 -Set 4-14034 …

View on Amazon

Best for: Light trail and golf-style use

This set suits riders who mostly cover packed trails, farm lanes and lightly used paths and want a lower ply count.

Pros

  • Lighter 4 ply build
  • Sized close to 23-inch class fitments

Cons

  • Not designed for heavy mud or hauling

View on Amazon

WANDA ATV Tires 24×10-12 24x10x12 /6PR Lit Mud, Set 2-10432

WANDA ATV Tires 24x10-12 24x10x12 /6PR Lit Mud, Set 2-10432

WANDA ATV Tires 24×10-12 24x10x12 /6PR Lit Mud, Set 2-10432

View on Amazon

Best for: Deep mud

Riders who spend weekends in wet, sloppy ground will find the aggressive mud tread a good match for this set.

Pros

  • Aggressive lug pattern for soft ground
  • 6 ply rating adds sidewall stiffness

Cons

  • Can feel noisy on pavement

View on Amazon

Set of 2 24×10-12 All-Terrain ATV UTV Tires, 6 Ply Tubeless

Set of 2 24x10-12 All-Terrain ATV UTV Tires, 6 Ply Tubeless, Heavy Duty Off-Road Tires for Mud and Sand, High Load Capacity and Durable Performance

Set of 2 24×10-12 All-Terrain ATV UTV Tires, 6 Ply Tubeless, Heavy Duty Off-Road Tires for Mud and Sand, High Load Capacity and Durable Performance

View on Amazon

Best for: Heavy loads

Owners hauling gear or towing will appreciate the 6 ply tubeless construction and the high load capacity the listing describes.

Pros

  • Tubeless design for easier repairs
  • Built for mud and sand

Cons

  • Heavier than lighter-duty sets

View on Amazon

ATV & UTV All Terrain All Season Traction 98A3 Rated 4 Ply WANDA Utility ATV Tire 23×11-10

ATV & UTV All Terrain All Season Traction 98A3 Rated 4 Ply Bias Construction Black Sidewall Tire WANDA Utility ATV Tire 23x11-10 23X11X10 High Load Capacity -10294

ATV & UTV All Terrain All Season Traction 98A3 Rated 4 Ply Bias Construction Black Sidewall Tire WANDA Utility ATV Tire 23×11-10 23X11X10 High Load Capacity -10294

View on Amazon

Best for: Utility use

This set fits farm, property and work riders who need a 98A3 load rating and an all-season tread for mixed surfaces.

Pros

  • 98A3 load rating
  • All-season traction

Cons

  • Narrower 11-inch width than 12-inch options

View on Amazon

WANDA POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs Set 4 All Terrain ATV Tires

POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs Cover All Terrains WANDA Set 4 All Terrain ATV Tires 24x8-12 & 24x10-11 6PR Power-Trail

POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs Cover All Terrains WANDA Set 4 All Terrain ATV Tires 24×8-12 & 24×10-11 6PR Power-Trail

View on Amazon

Best for: Mixed terrain

A good choice for riders who alternate between trails, gravel and firm dirt and want one set that handles all of it.

Pros

  • Non-directional lugs allow rotation
  • Balanced all-terrain tread

Cons

  • Less bite in deep mud than dedicated mud tires

View on Amazon

6-Ply Rated All Terrain ATV UTV Tire, Garvee Pack of 2 AT25x10-12

6-Ply Rated All Terrain ATV UTV Tire, 12 Inch Rim Tubeless 4 Wheeler Tire for Off-Road Mud Dirt Trails, Tubeless Garvee Pack of 2 AT25x10-12 ATV Tire

6-Ply Rated All Terrain ATV UTV Tire, 12 Inch Rim Tubeless 4 Wheeler Tire for Off-Road Mud Dirt Trails, Tubeless Garvee Pack of 2 AT25x10-12 ATV Tire

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget trail riding

Riders who want a 6 ply tubeless tire for trail use without paying for premium brand names may find this pair a fit.

Pros

  • 6 ply tubeless construction
  • Sold as a pair

Cons

  • Brand reputation is less established

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Ply Rating and Load Capacity

Ply rating indicates sidewall strength and how much weight a tire can carry. Match the rating to your heaviest typical load, including a passenger or cargo rack.

Tread Pattern

Aggressive lugs grip soft mud, while non-directional tread lasts longer on hardpack and mixed trails. Choose based on where you ride most.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our ATV, UTV/side-by-side & dirt bikes guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.