Updated November 2026

Choosing 26x9x12 26x11x12 ATV tires comes down to matching the staggered front and rear sizes to your rims, picking a tread that suits your terrain, and checking the ply rating for load. This list compares seven widely sold sets based on fit, tread design, construction and what owners commonly report. Every pick below is a 26-inch front and 26-inch rear pairing in the 9-inch front and 11-inch rear widths.

Best overall: ROADGUIDER Set 4 – View on Amazon
Best for mud: MCKINLEY UTV ATV Tires X611 – View on Amazon
Best for all-around use: Garvee Set of 4 All-Terrain Tires – View on Amazon
Best for classic trail lugs: WANDA POWER-TRAIL Set 4 – View on Amazon
Best for two- or four-wheel drive budgets: Non-Directional A Tread 2-Pack – View on Amazon
Best for heavy-duty sidewalls: Free Country 4 8PR Radial – View on Amazon
Best for scuff protection: Free Country Set 2 Premium 8PR – View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
ROADGUIDER Set 4 ATV/UTV Tire Overall fit Matched 10275/276 sizing
MCKINLEY UTV ATV Tires X611 Mud riding Super mud tread, 6-ply
Garvee Set of 4 ATV UTV Tires Mixed terrain Tubeless all-terrain build
WANDA POWER-TRAIL Set 4 Trail lug style Solid non-directional lugs
26x9x12 Non-Directional A Tread Budget 2-Pack Non-directional A tread
Free Country 4 8PR Radial UTV Heavy loads 8-ply radial, full sidewall lugs
Free Country Set 2 Premium 8PR Rock and brush Built-in scuff guard

ROADGUIDER Set 4 ATV/UTV Tire 26×9-12 26x9x12 & 26×11-12 26x11x12 10275/276

ROADGUIDER Set 4 ATV/UTV Tire 26x9-12 26x9x12 & 26x11-12 26x11x12 10275/276

ROADGUIDER Set 4 ATV/UTV Tire 26×9-12 26x9x12 & 26×11-12 26x11x12 10275/276

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall fit for the 26x9x12 front and 26x11x12 rear pairing.

This set suits riders who want a complete four-tire kit with the correct staggered sizes listed together, so ordering is straightforward.

Pros

  • Front and rear sizes listed together for easy matching
  • Suitable for general trail use

Cons

  • Owners often recommend checking sidewall stiffness on rocky trails

View on Amazon

MCKINLEY UTV ATV Tires 26X9-12 26X12-12 6PR Set4 Super Mud All Terrain X611

MCKINLEY UTV ATV Tires 26X9-12 26X12-12 6PR Set4 Super Mud All Terrain X611

MCKINLEY UTV ATV Tires 26X9-12 26X12-12 6PR Set4 Super Mud All Terrain X611

View on Amazon

Best for: Mud riding with deep, aggressive lug coverage.

Riders who spend most of their time in wet, soft ground and want a bigger bite will find this tread design the main draw.

Pros

  • Aggressive super mud tread pattern
  • 6-ply construction

Cons

  • Aggressive lugs can feel noisy on pavement

View on Amazon

Garvee Set of 4 ATV UTV Tires 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear, 6 PR Tubeless All-Terrain Tires

Garvee Set of 4 ATV UTV Tires 26x9-12 Front & 26x11-12 Rear, 6 PR Tubeless All-Terrain Tires for Mud, Dirt, Desert, Rock - Replacement Tires

Garvee Set of 4 ATV UTV Tires 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear, 6 PR Tubeless All-Terrain Tires for Mud, Dirt, Desert, Rock – Replacement Tires

View on Amazon

Best for: Mixed terrain covering mud, dirt, desert and rock.

This set fits riders who move between several surfaces and do not want a mud-specific tread that struggles on hard-packed trails.

Pros

  • Tubeless design listed for all-terrain use
  • Full four-tire set in matched sizes

Cons

  • Less bite in deep mud than dedicated mud tread

View on Amazon

POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs WANDA Set 4 ATV Tires 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear 6PR

POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs Cover All Terrains WANDA Set 4 ATV Tires 26x9-12 Front & 26x11-12 Rear 6PR P3501-10377/10378

POWER-TRAIL Series Classic Solid Non-Direction Lugs Cover All Terrains WANDA Set 4 ATV Tires 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear 6PR P3501-10377/10378

View on Amazon

Best for: Classic trail lug style on mixed terrain.

Riders who prefer a traditional solid-lug look and a non-directional tread that can be mounted on either side will appreciate this option.

Pros

  • Non-directional solid lugs allow flexible mounting
  • 6-ply rating

Cons

  • Owners sometimes report a firmer ride on rough ground

View on Amazon

2pcs 26x9x12 ATV Tires, 6 PR, Non-Directional “A” Tread

2pcs 26x9x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" Tread Fit for 2 Or 4 Wheel Drive Atv Applications ATV/UTV Tires 26x9-12,6-Ply Tubeless Tire,Set of 2

2pcs 26x9x12 ATV Tires,6 PR,Only Tire.Non-Directional "A" Tread Fit for 2 Or 4 Wheel Drive Atv Applications ATV/UTV Tires 26×9-12,6-Ply Tubeless Tire,Set of 2

View on Amazon

Best for: A budget two-tire replacement for either two- or four-wheel drive machines.

This 2-pack suits riders replacing a pair of worn fronts or rears rather than buying a full set of four.

Pros

  • Two-tire pack for partial replacement
  • Non-directional tread

Cons

  • Only two tires, so you must match the rest of your set

View on Amazon

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our ATV, UTV/side-by-side & dirt bikes guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.